Purpose
This procedure establishes a fair, consistent, and transparent process for students to appeal final course grades when they believe a grade was assigned in error or applied inconsistently with approved course policies. This procedure provides due process for students while respecting faculty academic judgment and ensuring compliance with Minnesota State policy and Higher Learning Commission expectations.
Grade Appeal Criteria
Students may appeal a final grade when they believe the grade is unfair, arbitrary, or capricious. The student bears the burden of proving there are sufficient grounds for changing a grade. The appeal process will provide due process for students and faculty. A student may appeal a final course grade on the grounds:
- the methods or criteria for evaluating academic performance as stated in the course syllabus were not adhered to in determining grades; or
- the instructor applied grading criteria unfairly; or
- the instructor erred in calculating the grade or recording the grade.
Step 1: Informal Resolution
Students must first attempt to resolve grade concerns informally.
Instructor Discussion
- The student contacts the course instructor within 5 business days after the final grade is posted to discuss the concern.
- The instructor responds to the student in writing with their decision.
If a grade change is warranted, the instructor initiates the Grade Change process and the appeal concludes.
Step 2: Formal Grade Appeal
If informal resolution does not resolve the concern, the student may submit a formal grade appeal.
The formal appeal must:
- Use the college's designated Formal Grade Appeal Form.
- Clearly state the basis for the appeal.
- Include all supporting documentation (e.g., syllabus, graded assignments, correspondence, evidence related to appeal criteria).
- Be submitted within five (5) business days after receipt of the instructor's written decision.
The record closes at the time the formal appeal is submitted. Later reviewers consider only the existing record, plus any written response solicited from the instructor/administrator as part of the process.
Review by Dean of Educational Services
- The Dean reviews submitted materials and may consult with the student and instructor.
- The instructor is given an opportunity to provide a written response.
- The Dean issues a written decision within five (5) business days of receiving the formal appeal.
- If the appeal is granted, the Dean initiates the grade change process and the appeal concludes.
- If the appeal is denied, the student may request review by the Grade Appeal Committee.
Step 3: Grade Appeal Committee Review
- The student must request committee review within five (5) business days of the Dean's decision.
- The Grade Appeal Committee consists of three faculty members outside the discipline of the appealed course.
The committee:
- Selects a chair;
- Reviews all documentation, including instructor response to student appeal;
- Deliberates and reaches a decision by majority vote;
- Submits a written recommendation to the Vice President of Academic and Student Affairs (VPASA) within five (5) business days of the committee meeting.
Final Decision
- The VPASA reviews the Grade Appeal Committee's recommendation and may consult with involved parties.
- The VPASA issues a written decision to the student, faculty member, and Dean within five (5) business days.
- The VPASA's decision is final.
- If a grade change is approved, the VPASA initiates the grade change process.
Timelines and Extensions
- Timelines may be extended by the VPASA in unusual or extenuating circumstances.
- Nothing in this procedure requires faculty to agree with a decision rendered through the appeal process.
Records and Confidentiality
All grade appeal documentation is maintained in accordance with:
- Minnesota Government Data Practices Act (MGDPA);
- Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA);
- Minnesota State records retention requirements
Discrimination/Harassment/Retaliation
If the student alleges the grade was impacted by discrimination/harassment/retaliation based on protected class, the matter is referred to the ATCC Designated Officer to be processed under Minnesota State Board Policy 1B.1 or 1B.3, and the grade appeal may be paused or handled in coordination with this process.